Plunger vs Plumbing Snake Which Should You Choose

When a drain clogs, picking the right tool between a plunger and a plumbing snake is crucial for a quick fix. This guide explains the key differences, best uses, and detailed steps for each, so you can tackle any blockage with confidence. Save time and money by learning which tool matches your plumbing problem.

Key Takeaways

• Plungers are for simple clogs: Use a plunger for shallow blockages in toilets, sinks, or showers where water is present. It uses suction to dislodge material.
• Plumbing snakes handle tough jobs: A plumbing snake (or auger) is better for deep, stubborn clogs caused by hair, grease, or objects that a plunger can’t move.
• Try the plunger first: Always start with a plunger because it’s easier, cheaper, and less likely to damage pipes. It often solves common clogs quickly.
• Match the tool to the drain: Use a flange plunger for toilets and a cup plunger for flat drains. For snakes, hand augers work for minor clogs, while motorized ones are for severe blockages.
• Safety and preparation matter: Wear gloves and eye protection, clear the area, and have towels ready to avoid messes when using either tool.
• Know when to call a pro: If neither a plunger nor plumbing snake works, or if you suspect tree roots or pipe damage, it’s time to contact a professional plumber.
• Maintain your tools: Clean plungers after use and store snakes properly to ensure they’re ready for next time, extending their lifespan.

Plunger vs Plumbing Snake: Which Should You Choose? A Complete How-To Guide

Hey there! Dealing with a clogged drain or toilet is no fun. It can turn a normal day into a stressful mess. But don’t worry—you have two powerful tools at your disposal: the plunger and the plumbing snake. Knowing which one to use can save you time, money, and frustration. In this guide, we’ll dive deep into the plunger vs plumbing snake debate. You’ll learn what each tool does, when to use it, and how to use it like a pro. By the end, you’ll be equipped to handle almost any clog yourself. Let’s get started!

What is a Plunger? Your First Line of Defense

A plunger is a simple, hand-held tool designed to clear clogs using suction and pressure. It’s a staple in most homes for good reason—it’s effective for many common blockages. When you think about plunger vs plumbing snake, the plunger is often the go-to first step.

There are two main types of plungers:

• Toilet Plunger (Flange Plunger): This has a soft rubber cup with an extended flange that fits into the toilet drain. It creates a tight seal in the curved toilet bowl.
• Cup Plunger (Sink Plunger): This has a simple rubber cup and is best for flat surfaces like sink, shower, or bathtub drains.

How does it work? When you push and pull the plunger, it moves water back and forth in the drain. This action can break up or dislodge the clog, allowing it to wash away. It’s perfect for clogs caused by toilet paper, soap scum, or small debris. Remember, a plunger works best when there’s water in the drain to create that suction.

What is a Plumbing Snake? For Tough Blockages

A plumbing snake, also called a drain auger, is a flexible metal cable that you feed into a drain to physically break up or retrieve a clog. In the plunger vs plumbing snake comparison, the snake is your heavy-duty option. It’s ideal when a plunger just isn’t enough.

Plumbing snakes come in different forms:

• Hand Crank Snake (Hand Auger): This is a manual tool with a crank handle. It’s great for minor to moderate clogs in sinks, showers, or toilets. You control the cable by turning the handle.
• Motorized Snake (Drain Machine): This is a powered version, often used by professionals or for severe clogs like tree roots in main lines. It’s more aggressive and can reach deeper into pipes.

How does it work? You insert the snake’s cable into the drain until it hits the clog. Then, by rotating it, you can hook onto the material or break it apart. Snakes are excellent for clogs caused by hair, grease, food particles, or even small objects stuck in pipes.

Plunger vs Plumbing Snake: A Detailed Comparison

Choosing between a plunger and a plumbing snake depends on the clog. Here’s a quick breakdown to help you decide:

• Cost: Plungers are cheap, usually under $20. Plumbing snakes cost more, from $30 for hand augers to over $100 for motorized ones.
• Ease of Use: Plungers are super easy—just pump and go. Snakes require a bit more skill and effort to maneuver correctly.
• Effectiveness: Plungers work well on soft, shallow clogs. Snakes tackle hard, deep blockages that plungers can’t reach.
• Risk of Damage: Plungers are very safe for pipes. Snakes, if used improperly, can scratch or damage pipes, especially in older homes.
• Best For: Use a plunger for toilets, sinks, and showers with water-filled drains. Use a snake for stubborn clogs, hair bunches, or when a plunger fails.

In the plunger vs plumbing snake decision, think about the clog’s severity. Start simple with a plunger, then escalate to a snake if needed.

How to Use a Plunger Correctly: Step-by-Step Guide

Using a plunger might seem straightforward, but doing it right makes all the difference. Follow these steps to clear that clog efficiently.

Step 1: Choose the Right Plunger

Pick the correct type for your drain. For toilets, use a flange plunger. For sinks or showers, use a cup plunger. Having both on hand is smart for any plunger vs plumbing snake scenario.

Step 2: Prepare the Area

Clear around the drain. Remove any items that might get in the way. For toilets, put down old towels to catch splashes. Wear rubber gloves to keep clean.

Step 3: Create a Good Seal

Place the plunger cup over the drain. Make sure it covers the opening completely. For toilets, the flange should go into the drain hole. Add a bit of petroleum jelly around the cup rim if needed for a tighter seal.

Step 4: Pump Vigorously

Push down gently at first to force out air, then pull up quickly. Repeat this pumping motion 10-15 times. Use steady, strong strokes. The goal is to build pressure that loosens the clog.

Step 5: Check for Success

After pumping, pull the plunger away. If water drains quickly, you’ve solved it! If not, try again a few more times. For sinks, you can run hot water to help flush debris.

Practical Tip: For double sinks, block the other drain with a wet cloth to focus pressure. Always clean your plunger with bleach and water after use to prevent germs.

How to Use a Plumbing Snake Correctly: Step-by-Step Guide

If the plunger doesn’t work, it’s time for a plumbing snake. Here’s how to use it safely and effectively.

Step 1: Wear Safety Gear

Put on gloves and safety glasses. Snaking can be messy, and you want to protect your hands and eyes from debris.

Step 2: Insert the Snake Cable

Feed the cable end into the drain slowly. For toilets, remove the plunger and insert the snake directly into the bowl. For sinks, you might need to remove the drain stopper first.

Step 3: Crank and Push

Turn the handle clockwise as you push the cable further in. Keep going until you feel resistance—that’s likely the clog. In the plunger vs plumbing snake battle, this is where the snake shines by reaching deep clogs.

Step 4: Break Up or Retrieve the Clog

Once at the clog, rotate the handle back and forth to hook or break the material. You might feel it give way. For objects, you can try to pull them out by retracting the cable slowly.

Step 5: Withdraw and Clean

Carefully pull the snake out, wiping the cable with rags as it comes to remove gunk. Dispose of any retrieved debris properly. Then, run hot water to clear leftover bits.

Practical Tip: Start with a hand auger before using a motorized snake. For motorized models, follow the manual closely to avoid pipe damage. Always disinfect the snake after use.

Plunger vs Plumbing Snake: Which Should You Choose?

Now, the big question: how do you pick between a plunger and a plumbing snake? Use this decision guide based on your situation.

• For toilet clogs: Start with a plunger. If it’s a simple paper clog, it should work. If you suspect a toy or hard object, go straight to a toilet snake.
• For sink or shower clogs: Try a plunger first for slow drains. If it’s hair or grease, a snake might be better from the start.
• For severe blockages: If water backs up in multiple fixtures, you might have a main line clog. A motorized snake is needed, but consider calling a pro.
• For preventive maintenance: Use a plunger occasionally to keep drains clear. Snakes are for active clogs, not routine care.

In the plunger vs plumbing snake choice, remember: plunger for speed and simplicity, snake for power and precision. Having both tools ready covers most home plumbing issues.

Troubleshooting: When Neither Tool Works

Sometimes, even with the best efforts, a clog persists. Here’s what to do if both plunger and plumbing snake fail.

• Check for vent issues: Plumbing vents can get blocked, causing slow drains. Look for roof vent blockages or call a plumber to inspect.
• Inspect for pipe damage: Old or corroded pipes might have collapses or leaks that tools can’t fix. A camera inspection by a pro can reveal this.
• Consider chemical drain cleaners: Use these cautiously—they can damage pipes and are harmful to skin. Only as a last resort, and never after snaking, as chemicals can react with metal.
• Call a professional plumber: If you’ve tried everything and the clog remains, or if you see sewage backup, it’s time to call an expert. They have advanced tools like hydro-jetters to clear anything.

In your plunger vs plumbing snake journey, knowing when to stop DIY is key to avoiding bigger problems.

Conclusion: Be Prepared for Any Clog

There you have it—a complete guide to the plunger vs plumbing snake dilemma. Both tools are essential for any homeowner. The plunger is your quick, easy fix for common clogs. The plumbing snake is your backup for tougher jobs. By understanding their strengths and following our steps, you can tackle most drain issues confidently. Keep these tools handy, maintain them well, and don’t hesitate to call a pro when needed. Happy plumbing!